SRSEC Reporting Desk

ASC 606: Revenue Recognition

What to check in your filing: Confirm each performance obligation, timing (point vs. over time) and significant judgments are disaggregated and explained, not boilerplate ASC 606 language.

16 staff comments from 10 companies. Outcomes: Agreed to revise: 9, Awaiting / response not in dataset: 4, Responded: 2, Explained / pushed back: 1

COMPUGEN LTD (CGEN) · 2026-07-17 · . Form 20-F for Fiscal Year Ended December 31, 2025 · Comment 1 Agreed to revise
Staff comment: Considering the significant research and development expenses you have historically incurred and expect to continue to incur, in future filings, please expand your disclosures to include disaggregated disclosures for your research and development expenses, for example by product candidates, by program, and/or by nature of costs. Please also disclose whether you track external costs by product candidates and/or by program, and if not, please disclose that fact and the reason in future filings. Note 2. Significant Accounting Policies j. Revenue Recognition, page F-16 letter →
Company response: The Company acknowledges the Staff’s Comment and respectfully advises the Staff that the Company tracks external research and development expenses on a clinical trial-specific basis while aggregating such expenses for its preclinical studies. The Company undertakes to provide disclosure substantially in the form presented below in its future filings with the Commission. Research and development expenses consist primarily of costs incurred for the discovery and development of our product candidates. Given the number of programs that we have and, because some of our clinical trials may combine more than one program, we track the external research and development costs incurred per clinical… response letter →
ASC 606: Revenue RecognitionR&D Expense DisclosureBusiness Description (Item 101)
COMPUGEN LTD (CGEN) · 2026-07-17 · . Form 20-F for Fiscal Year Ended December 31, 2025 · Comment 2 Agreed to revise
Staff comment: As it relates to your 2023 Gilead License Agreement, you disclose that you identified three distinct performance obligations and that the transaction price was allocated to these performance obligations based on their relative standalone selling price. Please revise your future filings to quantify the amount of the transaction price allocated to each unsatisfied (or partially satisfied) performance obligation as of the end of each reporting period and an explanation as to the period over which you expect to recognize the remaining revenue. In this regard, we note that $35.9 million remains unrecognized as deferred revenue, and that you expect to recognize 31% of the remaining performance… letter →
Company response: The Company respectfully advises the Staff that, upon inception of the 2023 Gilead License Agreement, it identified three performance obligations. The agreement also provided Gilead with an option to purchase drug supply of GS-0321. The Company concluded that this option did not provide a material right and therefore did not represent a separate performance obligation. During the first half of 2026, Gilead exercised its option to purchase additional goods and services related to the supply of GS-0321. The Company undertakes to update its disclosure in future filings with the Commission to reflect the exercise of this option. The Company further advises the Staff that revenue associated with… response letter →
ASC 606: Revenue RecognitionKPIs, Metrics & Earnings Calls
Clinuvel Pharmaceuticals Ltd (CUVL, CLVLF) · 2026-03-19 · · Comment 9 · Revenue, page F-8 Awaiting / response not in dataset
Staff comment: We acknowledge your response to prior comment 23 and partially reissue our comment. Please revise your footnotes or MD&A to disclose the amounts for each significant category of sales rebate and other variable consideration adjustment reflected in the periods presented. letter →
ASC 606: Revenue RecognitionMD&A: Results & Known Trends
Clinuvel Pharmaceuticals Ltd (CUVL, CLVLF) · 2026-03-19 · · Comment 10 · periods presented. Awaiting / response not in dataset
Staff comment: We note your disclosure on page 35 that changes in pricing of SCENESSE, from which you have consistently generated over 90% of your product sales, may have a severe impact on your operations, that you do not offer rebates or discounts on SCENESSE beyond statutory requirements and that you aim for uniform pricing per jurisdiction. As it appears that uniform pricing may coexist with expected rebates and other variable consideration with EEA and U.S. national or private insurers, whether stated or implicit, tell us how you considered whether any non-uniform elements exist, and if so, whether they are variable consideration that should be estimated and constrained in determining your… letter →
ASC 606: Revenue Recognition
Electromed, Inc. (ELMD) · 2026-03-16 · Form 10-K For the Fiscal Year Ended June 30, 2025 Filed August 26, 2025 · Comment 3 · Note 2. Revenues, page F-11 Awaiting / response not in dataset
Staff comment: Please provide us and in future filings the qualitative and quantitative disclosures related to the significant judgments, and changes in judgments, including information related to inputs and assumptions, as it relates to you estimating variable consideration. Refer to ASC 606-10-50-1(b), 50-17(b), and 50-20. As a related matter, consider disclosing in future filings the amount of capped installment payments as you disclose that the related transactions constitute a primary portion of your variable consideration. letter →
ASC 606: Revenue Recognition
AMDOCS LTD (DOX) · 2026-03-10 · Amdocs Limited Form 20-F for the Fiscal Year Ended September 30, 2025 · Comment 2 · Remaining Performance Obligations from Contracts with Customers, page F-19 Agreed to revise
Staff comment: We note your disclosure where you state given the profile of contract terms, the majority of the $6.4 billion of remaining performance obligations at September 30, 2025, are expected to be recognized as revenue over the next three years. Please revise to disclose when you expect to recognize such amounts as revenue on a quantitative basis using time bands that would be most appropriate for the duration of the remaining performance obligations (e.g. within one year, within two years, within three years and three years and beyond), or by providing qualitative information. Refer to ASC 606-10-50-13. letter →
Company response: The Company respectfully acknowledges the Staff’s comment and confirms that future annual reports on Form 20-F, including our Annual Report on Form 20-F for the fiscal year ending September 30, 2026, will disclose when we expect to recognize remaining performance obligations as revenue on a quantitative basis using time bands that would be most appropriate for the duration of the remaining performance obligations. A portion of the Company’s revenue relates to projects for which revenue is recognized over time based on a percentage that incurred labor effort to date bears to total projected labor effort. These projects may be executed over periods longer than one year, and the timing of… response letter →
ASC 606: Revenue Recognition
Karbon-X Corp. (KARX) · 2026-03-05 · Form 10-K for the Fiscal Year Ended May 31, 2025 Form 10-Q for the Quarter Ended November 30, 2025 · Comment 2 · Revenue Recognition, page F-9 Agreed to revise
Staff comment: Please explain how you account for revenue related to the sale of carbon credits. Specifically, tell us 1. The nature of the carbon credits, whether voluntary or for compliance; 2. How you determine when control of the carbon credits transfers to customers; 3. Any ongoing performance obligations after the sale; 4. How you determine the transaction price, including variable considerations due to regulatory or reversal risks. letter →
Company response: We generate revenue from the sale of carbon credits and from consulting and related services. Our environmental attributes are both compliance focused (such as Canada Federal OBPS or Alberta TIER) and voluntary focused (transacted withing Gold Standard, Verra, etc.). We apply ASC 606, Revenue from Contracts with Customers , to these arrangements. (1) Nature of the carbon credits Our contracts with customers typically involve the sale of environmental attributes that are either: · Project generated credits: Credits we originate or control through our participation in underlying projects (e.g., afforestation, reforestation, or other verified emissions reduction projects); or · Purchased… response letter →
ASC 606: Revenue Recognition
Karbon-X Corp. (KARX) · 2026-03-05 · Form 10-K for the Fiscal Year Ended May 31, 2025 Form 10-Q for the Quarter Ended November 30, 2025 · Comment 3 · Page 2 Agreed to revise
Staff comment: Explain how you determined that you are the principal in transactions involving the sale of carbon credits. In your response, describe how you assessed the indicators outlined in ASC 606-10-55-36 through 55-40. letter →
Company response: , describe how you assessed the indicators outlined in ASC 606‑10‑55‑36 through 55‑40. Response: We acknowledge the Staff’s comment and have evaluated whether we act as principal or agent in our carbon credit transactions under ASC 606‑10‑55‑36 through 55‑40. In most of our carbon credit sales, we conclude that we are the principal because we control the credits before they are transferred to the customer. Our assessment is based on the following indicators: · Control of the asset before transfer (ASC 606‑10‑55‑37): We obtain control of the credits either by (i) originating them through our project arrangements, or (ii) purchasing them from third parties and holding them in our registry… response letter →
ASC 606: Principal vs. AgentASC 606: Revenue Recognition
Karbon-X Corp. (KARX) · 2026-03-05 · Form 10-K for the Fiscal Year Ended May 31, 2025 Form 10-Q for the Quarter Ended November 30, 2025 · Comment 4 · ASC 606-10-55-36 through 55-40. Agreed to revise
Staff comment: Provide a rollforward of deferred revenue, including a breakdown of the underlying balances by current and non-current portions and discuss when you expect to recognize the related revenue as required by ASC 606-10-50-8 through 50-10. letter →
Company response: We acknowledge the Staff’s comment. We recognize that ASC 606‑10‑50‑8 through 50‑10 requires disclosure of the opening and closing balances of contract liabilities (deferred revenue), significant changes in those balances, and information about the timing of revenue recognition for remaining performance obligations. Below is a roll forward as requested. FY2025 (Year Ended May 31, 2025) Q2 FY2026 (Six Months Ended Nov 30, 2025) Opening balance $ - $ 3,864,080 Heidelberg deferred revenue $ 928,042 $ (928,042 ) DevvStream deferred revenue $ 2,936,038 $ - Other deferred revenue $ - $ 26,764 Currency translation $ - $ (47,901 ) Closing balance $ 3,864,080 $ 2,914,901 Current portion $ 3,864,080… response letter →
ASC 606: Principal vs. AgentASC 606: Revenue Recognition
Karbon-X Corp. (KARX) · 2026-03-05 · Form 10-K for the Fiscal Year Ended May 31, 2025 Form 10-Q for the Quarter Ended November 30, 2025 · Comment 5 · the related revenue as required by ASC 606-10-50-8 through 50-10. Responded
Staff comment: In future filings, please provide your revenue disaggregation in accordance with ASC 606-10-50-5, 606-10-55-89 through 55-91. It appears you have revenue generated from selling carbon credits and providing consulting services. letter →
Company response: We acknowledge the Staff’s comment. We agree that our revenue should be disaggregated to depict how the nature, amount, timing, and uncertainty of revenue and cash flows are affected by economic factors, as required by ASC 606‑10‑50‑5 and 55‑89 through 55‑91. In future Annual Reports on Form 10‑K and, where material, Quarterly Reports on Form 10‑Q, we will disaggregate revenue by type of good or service and, if relevant, by geographic region or market. We will also provide the required narrative discussion linking the disaggregated revenue to our segment information (if applicable) and to our revenue recognition policies. Form 10‑Q for the Quarter Ended November 30, 2025 6 Item 2.… response letter →
ASC 606: Revenue Recognition
ELITE PHARMACEUTICALS INC /NV/ (ELTP) · 2026-03-04 · Elite Pharmaceuticals, Inc. Form 10-K for the Fiscal Year Ended March 31, 2025 Filed June 30, 2025 · Comment 1 · Revenue Recognition, page F-8 Agreed to revise
Staff comment: We note your disaggregation of revenue disclosure provided on page F-9 as well as the information provided in your February 20, 2024 response letter, specifically your response to comment four. You state that you disaggregate your revenue based on type of good or service (e.g., manufacturing and license fees) and regulatory pathway (e.g., ANDA vs NDA). Please address the following: • Given that you have paused further development of NDAs and do not appear to have engaged in business activities in this segment since 2021, explain to us how disaggregation by regulatory pathway provides a meaningful level of disaggregation of your revenues. • In your February 20, 2024 response to prior comment… letter →
Company response: letter, specifically your response to comment four. You state that you disaggregate your revenue based on type of good or service (e.g., manufacturing and license fees) and regulatory pathway (e.g., ANDA vs NDA). Please address the following: ● Given that you have paused further development of NDAs and do not appear to have engaged in business activities in this segment since 2021, explain to us how disaggregation by regulatory pathway provides a meaningful level of disaggregation of your revenues. U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission ● In your February 20, 2024 response to prior comment four, you stated that when determining the level of revenue disaggregation, you considered the… response letter →
ASC 606: Revenue RecognitionSegment Reporting (ASC 280)Risk Factors
OneConstruction Group Ltd (ONEG) · 2026-02-12 · Form 20-F for the Fiscal Year Ended March 31, 2025 · Comment 1 · Revenue Recognition, page F-9 Explained / pushed back
Staff comment: We note your discussion of defects liability periods on page 43. Please tell us what consideration you gave to addressing your accounting policy for defects liability periods within your revenue recognition policy. letter →
Company response: The Company respectfully advises the Staff that with respect to the defects liability period, the clients of the Company's operating subsidiary may retain up to 5% to 10% of each payment to be made to the operating subsidiary, as retention monies. The defects liability period does not represent a separate performance obligation and therefore does not impact the timing of revenue recognition. The defects liability period is merely a warranty in nature, and it is not an additional service provided to the customer. It does not increase the scope of work done in a construction project, and does not constitute a distinct service. Revenue is recognized when the construction work services were… response letter →
ASC 606: Revenue Recognition
Clinuvel Pharmaceuticals Ltd (CUVL, CLVLF) · 2026-01-30 · · Comment 23 · Revenue, page 45 Awaiting / response not in dataset
Staff comment: We note your disclosure on page F-8 that revenue is reduced for variable consideration when control of the product transfers. Please revise to disclose the types and amounts of variable consideration and the significant judgments and estimates involved in its measurement. letter →
ASC 606: Revenue Recognition
Chewy, Inc. (CHWY) · 2026-01-15 · Form 10-K for Fiscal Year Ended February 2, 2025 Filed March 26, 2025 · Comment 1 · Revenue Recognition, page 60 Agreed to revise
Staff comment: We note you generate revenue from the sale of pet products. We also note your emphasis on pet healthcare, including the provision of pharmacy, veterinary, and telehealth services. As it relates to these expanded service-based offerings, please explain your consideration of Rule 5-03(b) of Regulation S-X requiring separate presentation of revenue and costs of revenue from products, services and other revenues; ASC-606-10-50-5 and 606-10-55-89 through 55-91 requiring disclosure of disaggregated revenue recognized from contracts with customers into categories that depict how the nature, amount, timing, and uncertainty of revenue and cash flows are affected by economic factors; and ASC… letter →
Company response: The Company confirms that management considered Rule 5-03(b) of Regulation S-X and the guidance under ASC-606-10-50-5, ASC 606-10-55-89 through 55-91 and ASC 280-10-50-40 in evaluating the Company’s presentation of revenue and costs of revenue. In evaluating the presentation of revenues and costs of revenues under Rule 5-03(b) of Regulation S-X, management considered whether the Company’s revenues from products, services, and other activities warrant separate presentation on the face of the consolidated statements of operations. Rule 5-03(b) of Regulation S-X provides that “ if income is derived from more than one of the sub-captions described under § 210.5-03.1, each class which is not… response letter →
ASC 606: Revenue RecognitionSegment Reporting (ASC 280)Financial Statement Requirements (Reg S-X)
SemiLEDs Corp (LEDS) · 2026-01-12 · Form 10-K for the fiscal year ended August 31, 2025 Filed November 28, 2025 · Comment 1 · Revenue Recognition, page 52 Agreed to revise
Staff comment: We note your new business initiative (i.e., buy-sell orders of equipment) has significantly impacted your revenues and cost of revenues. Please address the following items. • In future filings, expand your disclosure (here and within your critical accounting policies and estimates on page 33) to clearly discuss buy-sell orders of equipment and your related accounting policies, including but not limited to gross versus net accounting treatment. • Provide to us supplementally your assessment of ASC 606 in your determination of whether to present revenue on a gross or net basis. In this regard, ensure your response addresses principal versus agent considerations as discussed in ASC… letter →
Company response: addresses principal versus agent considerations as discussed in ASC 606-10-55-36 through 40. Response: We have expanded our disclosures in the Summary of Significant Accounting Policies - Revenue Recognition in footnote 2 to Notes to Unaudited Condensed Consolidated Financial Statements and in Item 2. Management’s Discussion and Analysis of Financial Condition and Results of Operations - Critical Accounting Policies End estimates in our Form 10-Q for the first fiscal quarter ended November 30, 2025 filed on January 14, 2026, and will continue disclosing them plus the new language in brackets below in our future filings. We added the following disclosures: Gross Versus Net Revenue ASC 606… response letter →
ASC 606: Principal vs. AgentASC 606: Revenue Recognition
Cloopen Group Holding Ltd (RAASY) · 2025-11-21 · · Comment 4 · Revenue Recognition, page F-21 Responded
Staff comment: We note that you provide services as an agent in provision of CPaaS platforms to customers and recognize the related revenue on a net basis. We further note you disclose the “gross amount of revenue from services as an agent” for each period presented. Please tell us how you considered whether your discussion of revenue on a gross basis presents a non-GAAP measure and tell us how you considered the guidance in Item 10(e)(ii)(c) of Regulation S-K and the Question 100.04 of the Non-GAAP C&DIs. letter →
Company response: The Company respectfully clarifies that the previously disclosed “gross amount of revenue” was intended as an operational metric. In response to the Staff’s comment, the Company respectfully undertakes to revise the relevant disclosure in its future Form 20-F filings as follows (with deletions shown in strikethrough showing the changes against the disclosure in the 2024 Form 20-F), subject to such updates and adjustments to be made in connection with any material developments of the subject matter being disclosed. “ NOTES TO THE CONSOLIDATED FINANCIAL STATEMENTS … 2. SUMMARY OF SIGNIFICANT ACCOUNTING POLICIES … (s) Revenue recognition … 5 CPaaS revenues The Company accounts for revenue from… response letter →
ASC 606: Principal vs. AgentASC 606: Revenue RecognitionNon-GAAP: Adjustments & LabelsNon-GAAP: Reconciliation & Usefulness
Free weekly digest

New SEC comment letters by topic, notable staff comments, fresh disclosure examples and effective-date reminders. One email a week.

Templates & resources

Listed alphabetically by provider. Listings are not endorsements; no provider pays for placement. All templates & resources